A Changing Regulatory Landscape Calls for a More Coordinated Approach
On October 22, we were delighted to welcome representatives from more than 20 multinational companies to the first Quarterly Collaborative of Sustainability Roundtable, Inc.’s Comprehensive Compliance Collaborative (CCC). It was a remarkable gathering of corporate sustainability leaders, legal experts, and experienced practitioners, working together to navigate an increasingly complicated world of mandatory sustainability reporting. Our discussions covered California’s emerging reporting requirements, Europe’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), evolving assurance expectations, and the practical challenges companies face in preparing their organizations. Perhaps most encouraging was the willingness of participating executives to share experiences, ask difficult questions, and learn from one another. This is precisely why we launched the Collaborative.
And what a difference a few weeks make.
Since our October 22 meeting, the regulatory landscape has continued to shift, with consequential developments in California, Europe, and corporate decarbonization standards. For sustainability leaders already managing substantial workloads, the pace of change is extraordinary.
On November 9, just one day before California’s first mandatory greenhouse gas reporting deadline, the Ninth Circuit issued a significant decision concerning SB 253 and SB 261. The court affirmed the denial of preliminary relief against SB 253’s Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting requirements, allowing the November 10 reporting deadline to proceed. But the court reversed the denial of preliminary relief concerning SB 253’s Scope 3 requirements and SB 261’s climate-related financial risk disclosures, raising substantial questions about their future implementation. The decision concerns preliminary relief, not a final judgment invalidating either statute. Further proceedings will determine how the affected requirements move forward. For companies preparing their first emissions disclosures, the immediate lesson is clear.
Mandatory reporting is no longer a distant prospect. It has begun. And the requirements governing future reporting periods remain subject to change. Companies must continue meeting applicable obligations while carefully reassessing the timing, scope, and resources committed to requirements affected by the decision.
Across the Atlantic, Europe’s Omnibus reforms have substantially narrowed the scope of the CSRD and simplified elements of the reporting framework. Many companies that previously expected to report are now reassessing their obligations. Others remain within scope and must prepare for reporting and assurance under revised requirements.
Three developments bring the requirements into sharper focus. The simplified European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) entered into force on November 10, generally applying to financial years beginning in 2027. EFRAG's consultation on ESRS-40a, the proposed reporting standards for certain non-EU parent companies, closed on October 31, with final technical advice expected in January 2027. And on November 12, the European Commission opened a consultation on a proposed EU limited assurance standard for CSRD reporting, with feedback due January 18, 2027. Building on ISSA 5000 with EU-specific adaptations, the proposal offers an important early indication of how assurance providers may evaluate sustainability disclosures, including EU Taxonomy reporting.
For U.S.-headquartered multinationals, these changes create both opportunity and uncertainty. Companies should avoid spending heavily on obligations that may no longer apply. But those remaining in scope cannot afford to defer the development of reliable data, reporting processes, and internal accountability indefinitely. The challenge is to distinguish what must be done now from what can reasonably wait.
Voluntary standards are changing alongside mandatory reporting. Earlier this month, the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) proposed clarifications to the electricity criteria in its Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 2.0. These proposals address important questions surrounding renewable electricity procurement, geographic deliverability, and the treatment of long-term contracts that help finance new clean energy capacity. While the proposals remain subject to consultation, they have significant implications for companies pursuing science-based targets. They also illustrate a broader challenge.
Companies must understand how their decarbonization investments support voluntary targets, how associated energy attributes are reflected in greenhouse gas inventories, and how those inventories are used in mandatory disclosures. These are connected decisions, but they are not governed by identical requirements. A renewable electricity contract may support progress against an SBTi target under one set of criteria while its treatment in a market-based Scope 2 inventory is governed by the GHG Protocol. The underlying records and decisions must be sufficiently clear to support each relevant claim.
Sustainability strategy and mandatory reporting cannot be managed in isolation.
The developments of the past few weeks reinforce a challenge we hear repeatedly from corporate sustainability executives. How can companies manage changing regulations without repeatedly rebuilding their reporting programs? Consider a multinational preparing for California reporting, assessing CSRD applicability, monitoring ISSB adoption, and maintaining voluntary climate commitments. Each framework has distinct reporting boundaries, disclosure requirements, and assurance expectations. Yet the underlying work often overlaps.
Energy and greenhouse gas data must be collected. Reporting methodologies must be documented. Responsibilities must be assigned. Management judgments must be supported. Evidence must be maintained for internal review and eventual assurance. Establishing separate processes for each obligation can create unnecessary cost, duplicated effort, and inconsistent information.
We believe companies should instead build one coordinated reporting program that supports multiple regulatory outputs.
This does not mean treating different regulations as interchangeable. It means establishing a common foundation of reliable data, reporting controls, accountable owners, and reusable evidence, while retaining the flexibility to meet each framework’s specific requirements. A coordinated program can also help organizations respond more efficiently when regulations change. Rather than starting over, companies can update their applicability assessments, adjust priorities, and preserve the work that remains valuable.
For many companies, the greatest challenge is not simply interpreting the regulations. It is finding the capacity to implement them.
Sustainability professionals are increasingly responsible for coordinating data across geographies and business functions, preparing disclosures, responding to assurance providers, and maintaining the organization’s broader decarbonization strategy. Finance and legal teams are becoming more involved, but responsibilities and processes are often still evolving. This creates a need for a more disciplined sustainability reporting operating model. We think of this as the emerging ESG Controller function. Like financial reporting, sustainability reporting increasingly requires documented methodologies, defined responsibilities, internal controls, evidence management, and effective coordination with independent assurance providers. Not every organization needs to build an entirely new internal department. But every organization subject to significant reporting requirements needs to determine how these capabilities will be provided.
That is where a combination of internal accountability, experienced external advisers, and carefully applied technology can make a meaningful difference.
We launched our Comprehensive Compliance Collaborative to help address these challenges in a more effective and cost-efficient way. The CCC brings together multinational companies, experienced sustainability practitioners, and subject-matter experts to share insights, monitor evolving requirements, and develop practical approaches to mandatory reporting. Our first Quarterly Collaborative on October 22 demonstrated the value of bringing executives together to learn from real implementation experiences.
The CCC builds on SR Inc’s established Strategic Roundtable, which helps Member Executives advance sustainability strategies, targets, and decarbonization initiatives through an agreed Member Advisory Plan (MAP). Each CCC Member-client also works from a Compliance Action Plan (CAP), which translates regulatory developments into actionable priorities, decisions, and responsibilities.
For organizations requiring additional execution capacity, our ESG Controller Support managed service helps put those plans into practice. This includes reporting coordination, internal controls, evidence management, documentation, and assurance readiness.
Our objective is straightforward: help companies manage mandatory reporting with greater confidence, less duplication, and more effective use of their internal resources.
The Strategic Roundtable helps shape the strategy. The CCC helps determine the compliance priorities. ESG Controller Support helps turn those priorities into a reliable, repeatable reporting process. These services are designed to work together, not compete with one another.
The extraordinary pace of regulatory change since our first Quarterly Collaborative demonstrates why ongoing engagement matters.
The questions facing sustainability leaders cannot be answered through a single advisory, webinar, or legal update. They require continuing attention, informed judgment, and practical coordination across functions.
We welcome the opportunity to discuss your organization’s mandatory reporting priorities and how SR Inc.’s Strategic Roundtable, Comprehensive Compliance Collaborative, and ESG Controller Support services can help.
We are also looking forward to our upcoming December 17 CCC session focused on Information and Communications Technology (ICT) and Life Sciences (HLS).
This session will bring together interested companies in these sectors to discuss evolving reporting obligations, implementation challenges, and practical approaches to compliance and assurance readiness. If your organization operates in either sector, we would be pleased to discuss participation. Please reach out here: info@sustainround.com.
The rules will continue to change. Our goal is to help sustainability leaders stay ahead of them, learn from one another, and build reporting programs that are both rigorous and practical.
Regulatory developments discussed are current as of November 17, 2026. Applicability and reporting obligations depend on company-specific facts and applicable law.